only given this a 3, due to sizing and price. the good: lovely shade of blue. the cut is great with a nice graduation from waist to the wide leg bottoms. nice weight, not too heavy, but not flimsy. the bad: i'm 5ft and I bought the petite. The leg length is about 3 inches too long, so had to return. Also,they are expensive for what they are, I found a similar item elsewhere for half the price in the end, bought in 'short' length, and its perfect. Next petite lengths are always really good for me, but this is the Emma Willis collection, so diff sizing I guess.